Sopheap Keo Child-Rearing and Discipline among Cambodian Americans

TABLES



The columns may not align if you are reading this in a text size other than medium. If you are using Internet Explorer, this may be easily remedied by clicking view on your tool bar, scrolling down to text size, and clicking medium. Perfect alignment is not possible on Netscape Navigator.


TABLE 1. Demographic and Descriptive Characteristics of Respondents (N = 50)

_____________________________________________________________________

Characteristic					f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Age
	18-28					24		48.0
	29-39					13		26.0
	40-50					 5		10.0
	51+					 8		16.0

Gender
	Female					29		58.0
	Male					21		42.0

Arrive in United Statesa
	Early 1979 or before			 2		 4.1
	Late 1979 or After			49		95.9

Age Enter United Statesa
	18 Years Old or Younger			32		68.1
	19 Years Old or Older			15		31.9

Marital Status
	Married					14		28.0
	Divorced				 2		 4.0
	Widowed					 3		 6.0
	Single					31		62.0

Householda
	Two Parents				27		55.1
	Single Parents				 7		14.3
	Step-Parents				 1		 2.0
	Extended Family				 5		10.2
	Other					 9		18.4

Are You a Parent?a
	Yes					18		37.5
	No					30		62.5

If Yes, Number of Children Presently Living 
with Them Presentlya
	1					 1		 7.7
	2					 5		38.5
	3					 2		15.4
	4					 3		23.1
	5					 2		15.4

TABLE 1.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Characteristic					f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Level of Educationa
	University Graduate			14		28.6
	Some University				 8		16.3
	Junior or Community College		10		20.4
	High School				 8		16.3
	Some Elementary School			 2		 4.1
	Other					 7		14.3

Type of Incomea
	Public Assistance			14		29.2
	Self-Employment				 1		 2.1
	Unemployment				 1		 2.1
	Employment Full-Time			16		33.3
	Employment Part-Time			12		25.0
	Other					 4		 8.3

Approximate Gross Family Incomea
	0-$19,999				27		55.1
	$20,000-39,999				13		26.5
	$40,000-59,999				 5		10.2
	$60,000-79,999				 3		 6.1
	$80,000+				 1		 2.0
_____________________________________________________________________
a Contained missing data.

TABLE 2. Respondents' Attitudes Toward Discipline of Children (N = 50)
_____________________________________________________________________

Item						  f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
It would be a disgrace if a child yelled at his/her parents.
	Strongly disagree			 2		 4.0
	Disagree				 7		14.0
	Agree					19		38.0
	Strongly agree				20		40.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 2		 4.0

Sometimes children know more than his/her parents.
	Strongly disagree			 3		 6.0
	Disagree				 8		16.0
	Agree					30		60.0
	Strongly agree				 7		14.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 2		 4.0

Parents need to be strict to keep their children in line.a
	Strongly disagree			 3		 6.1
	Disagree				10		20.4
	Agree					20		40.8
	Strongly agree				16		32.7

Parents sometimes need to use physical punishment to 
teach their children right from wrong.
	Strongly disagree			 4		 8.0
	Disagree				13		26.0
	Agree					16		32.0
	Strongly agree				16		32.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 1		 2.0

Parents decide what is best for their children.
	Strongly disagree			 3		 6.0
	Disagree				14		28.0
	Agree					17		34.0
	Strongly agree				13		26.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 3		 6.0

Parents should have the right to use any method of 
discipline with their children.
	Strongly disagree			 8		16.0
	Disagree				11		22.0
	Agree					13		26.0
	Strongly agree				16		32.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 2		 4.0

TABLE 2.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item						  f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Children who are bad need to feel ashamed and guilty.
	Strongly disagree			 8		16.0
	Disagree				13		26.0
	Agree					18		36.0
	Strongly agree				 9		18.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 2		 4.0

Children should not tell their parents what to do.
	Strongly disagree			 4		 8.0
	Disagree				19		38.0
	Agree					15		30.0
	Strongly agree				11		22.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 1		 2.0

Parents know better than their children.
	Strongly disagree			 4		 8.0
	Disagree				19		38.0
	Agree					16		32.0
	Strongly agree				 7		14.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 4		 8.0

The belief that parents abuse their children is absurd.
	Strongly disagree			 7		14.0
	Disagree				18		36.0
	Agree					13		26.0
	Strongly agree				 9		18.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 3		 6.0

Parents with conservative/traditional values have 
obedient children.
	Strongly disagree			 9		18.0
	Disagree				11		22.0
	Agree					14		28.0
	Strongly agree				 7		14.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 9		18.0

Parents should have the rights to use corporal 
punishment.
	Strongly disagree			 9		18.0
	Disagree				19		38.0
	Agree					11		22.0
	Strongly agree				 9		18.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 2		 4.0

TABLE 2.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item						 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Time out and reasoning does not work with children.
	Strongly disagree			 7		14.0
	Disagree				24		48.0
	Agree					 9		18.0
	Strongly agree				 7		14.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 3		 6.0

It is not acceptable for children to voice their opinion 
if they disagree with their parents.
	Strongly disagree			13		26.0
	Disagree				18		36.0
	Agree					 7		14.0
	Strongly agree				 9		18.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 3		 6.0

It is inappropriate for parents to accept faults.
	Strongly disagree			16		32.0
	Disagree				20		40.0
	Agree					 5		10.0
	Strongly agree				 3		 6.0
	No opinion/Not sure			 6		12.0
_____________________________________________________________________
a Contained missing data.

TABLE 3. Respondents' Methods of Discipline (N = 50)
_____________________________________________________________________

				  Physical	Emotional	Reasoning
Item				  f	%	f	%	f	%
_____________________________________________________________________
A child fails in school.	  1   2.0	1  2.0		48	96.0

A child refuses to share	  1   2.0	1  2.0		47	95.9 
toys.a

A child refuses to clean 	  2   4.0	1  2.0		47	94.0
his/her room.

A child receives bad grades.	  0   0.0	3  6.0		47	94.0

A child acts too young for 	  1   2.0	4  8.0		45	90.0
his/her age.

A child refuses to do the 	  4   8.2	1  2.0		44	89.8
dishes.a

A child makes fun of others.a	  2   4.1	3  6.1		44	89.8

A child cries a lot.a		  4   8.3	1  2.1		43	89.6

A child tells parents a lie.	  6  12.0	0  0.0		44	88.0

A child draws on the wall.	  6  12.0	0  0.0		44	88.0

A child cheats on a test.	  3   6.0	3  6.0		44	88.0

A child does not do his/her 	  2   4.0	4  8.0		44	88.0
homework.

A child complains or is 	  4   8.0	4  8.0		42	84.0
whiney.

A child jumps on the sofa.	  8  16.0	1  2.0		41	82.0

A child runs away from		  4   8.2	7 14.3		38	77.6
home.a

A child disrespects adults 	 12  24.0	0  0.0		37	75.5
or authorities.

A child is caught using 	  9  18.4	3  6.1		37	75.5
profanity.a

TABLE 3.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

				 Physical	Emotional	Reasoning
Item				 f	%	f	%	f	%
_____________________________________________________________________
A child is cruel to others.a	11  22.4	1  2.0		37	75.5

A child is truant from school.	10  20.0	3  6.0		37	74.0

A child got suspended from 	 9  18.4	4  8.2		36	73.5
school.a

A child refuses to go to 	10  20.0	4  8.0		36	72.0
school.

A child smokes cigarettes.	11  22.0	4  8.0		35	70.0

A child argues often with 	10  20.0	5 10.0		35	70.0
parents or other adults.

A child bites a friend.		13  26.0	2  4.0		35	70.0

A child goes out without 	 9  18.0	9 18.0		32	64.0
permission.

A child does not listen to 	15  30.0	3  6.0		32	64.0
his/her parents.

A child talks back to his/	13  26.0	6 12.0		31	62.0
her parents.

A child steals from stores.	19  38.0	1  2.0		30	60.0

A child uses marijuana.		15  30.0	8 16.0		27	54.0

A child curses at parents.a	22  44.9	4  8.2		23	46.9
_____________________________________________________________________
a Contained missing data.

TABLE 4. Respondents' Acculturation Level (N = 50)
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
What languages can you speak?
	Khmer only					  9		18.0
	Mostly Khmer, some English			  8		16.0
	Khmer and English about equally well (bilingual) 15		30.0
	Mostly English, some Khmer			 18		36.0
	Only English					  0		 0.0

What languages do you prefer?
	Khmer only					  9		18.0
	Mostly Khmer, some English			  8		16.0
	Khmer and English about equally well (bilingual) 16		32.0
	Mostly English, some Khmer			 17		34.0
	Only English					  0		 0.0

How do you identify yourself?a
	Asian						  5		10.2
	Asian American					  2		 4.1
	Cambodian (Khmer) American			 41		83.7
	American					  0		 0.0
	Other						  1		 2.0

What is the ethnic origin of the friends and peers 
that you have?
  Almost exclusively Cambodian, Cambodian Americans, 	 15		30.0
    other Asian or Orientals
  Mostly Cambodian Americans, other Asian or Orientals	 12		24.0
    About equally Cambodian groups, other Asian or	 20		40.0
  Oriental groups and Anglo groups
  Mostly Anglo, Blacks, Hispanics, or other non-Asian 	  1		 2.0
    ethnic groups
  Almost exclusively Anglos, Blacks, Hispanics or other   2		 4.0
    non-Asian ethnic groups

Whom do you associate with in your community?
  Almost exclusively Cambodian, Cambodian Americans, 	 11		22.0
    other Asian or Orientals
  Mostly Cambodian Americans, other Asian or Orientals	 19		38.0
  About equally Cambodian groups, other Asian or 	 16		32.0
    Oriental groups and Anglo groups
  Mostly Anglo, Blacks, Hispanics, or other non-Asian 	  3		 6.0
    ethnic groups
  Almost exclusively Anglos, Blacks, Hispanics or other   1		 2.0
    non-Asian ethnic groups

TABLE 4.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
If you could pick, whom would you prefer to associate 
with in the community?
  Almost exclusively Cambodian, Cambodian Americans, 	 11		22.0
    other Asian or Orientals
  Mostly Cambodian Americans, other Asian or Orientals	  9		18.0
  About equally Cambodian groups, other Asian or 	 25		50.0
    Oriental groups and Anglo groups
  Mostly Anglo, Blacks, Hispanics, or other non-Asian 	  5		10.0
    ethnic groups
  Almost exclusively Anglos, Blacks, Hispanics or other   0		 0.0
    non-Asian ethnic groups

What is your music preference?a
	Only Cambodian (Khmer)				  9		18.4
	Mostly Cambodian (Khmer)			  3		 6.1
	Equally Cambodian (Khmer) and English		 18		36.7
	Mostly English					 14		28.6
	English only					  5		10.2

What is your movie preference?
	Cambodian (Khmer) language movies only		 10		20.0
	Cambodian (Khmer) language movies mostly	  3		 6.0
	Equally Cambodian (Khmer)/English		 15		30.0
	English language movies mostly			 17		34.0
	English language movies only			  5		10.0

Where were you born?
	United States					  3		 6.0
	Cambodia					 39		78.0
	Other						  8		16.0

Where was your father born?
	Cambodia					48		96.0
	Other						 2		 4.0

Where was your mother born?
	Cambodia					48		96.0
	Other						 2		 4.0

Where was your father's father born?
	Cambodia					45		90.0
	Other						 5		10.0

TABLE 4.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Where was your father's mother born?
	Cambodia					47		94.0
	Other						 3		 6.0

Where was your mother's father born?
	Cambodia					45		90.0
	Other						 5		10.0

Where was your mother's mother born?
	Cambodia					45		90.0
	Other						 5		10.0

On the basis of the above answers, which of the following 
generation best applies to you.a
	1st generation					34		82.9
	2nd generation					 4		 9.8
	Don't know					 3		 7.3

Where were you raised?
	In Cambodia only				14		28.0
	Mostly in Cambodia, some in other
	  and some in United States	 		 3		 6.0
	Equally in Cambodia, other,
	  and United States				 2		 4.0
	Mostly in United States, some in
	  Cambodia, and some in other			20		40.0
	In United States only				11		22.0

What contact have you had with Cambodia?a
	Raised one year or more in Cambodia		18		37.5
	Lived for less than one year in Cambodia	 2		 4.2
	Occasional visits to Cambodia			 6		12.5
	Occasional communications (letters,
	  phone calls, etc.) with people in Cambodia	13		27.1
	No exposure or communication with
	  people in Cambodia	  			 9		18.8

What is your food preference at home?
	Exclusively Cambodian food			16		32.0
	Mostly Cambodian food, some American		22		44.0
	About equally Cambodian and American		12		24.0

What is your food preference in restaurants?
	Exclusively Cambodian food			12		24.0
	Mostly Cambodian food, some American		14		28.0
	About equally Cambodian and American		22		44.0
	Mostly American food				 2		 4.0

TABLE 4.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Do you reada
	Only Khmer					  7		14.3
	Khmer better than English			  5		10.2
	Khmer and English equally well			  6		12.2
	English better than Khmer			 18		36.7
	Only English					 13		26.5

Do you writea
	Only Khmer					  8		16.3
	Khmer better than English			  5		10.2
	Khmer and English equally well			  5		10.2
	English better than Khmer			 16		32.7
	Only English					 15		30.6

If you consider yourself Cambodian, how much pride 
do you have in this ethnic group?
	Extremely proud					 24		48.0
	Moderately proud				 23		46.0
	Little pride					  2		 4.0
	No pride but do not feel negative toward group	  1		 2.0
	No pride but do feel negative toward group	  0		 0.0

How would you rate yourself?
	Very Cambodian					 13		26.0
	Mostly Cambodian				 14		28.0
	Bicultural					 18		36.0
	Mostly Westernized				  3		 6.0
	Very Westernized				  2		 4.0

Do you participate in Cambodian occasions, holidays, 
traditions, etc.?
	Nearly all					 18		36.0
	Most of them					 17		34.0
	Some of them					 12		24.0
	A few of them					  3		 6.0
	None at all					  0		 0.0


TABLE 4.  Continued
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							 f		%
_____________________________________________________________________
Which of the following statements best describes 
your view of yourself?a
  I consider myself basically Cambodian.  		20		40.8
    Even though I live and work in America, I 
    still view myself basically as a Cambodian person.
  I consider myself basically as an American.  		 1		 2.0
    Even though I have an Asian background and 
    characteristics, I still view myself as an American.
  I consider myself as a Cambodian American, 		11		22.4
    although deep down I always know I am Cambodian.
  I consider myself as a Cambodian American, 		 1		 2.0
    although deep down, I view myself as an American first.
  I consider myself as a Cambodian American.  		16		32.7
    I have both Cambodian and American characteristics, 
    and I view myself as a blend of both.
_____________________________________________________________________
a Contained missing data.

TABLE 5. Respondents' Rating of Values and Fit (N = 50)
_____________________________________________________________________

Item							M		SD
_____________________________________________________________________

Rate yourself on how much you believe 
in Cambodian values (e.g., about marriage, 		4.02		0.96
families, education, work):a 					

Rate yourself on how much you believe 
in American (Western) values:a				3.44		0.88


Rate yourself on how well you fit 
when with other Cambodian:b				4.04		0.95

Rate yourself on how well you fit 
when with Americans (Westerners) who 			3.36		1.22
are non-Asian or Cambodian:b
_____________________________________________________________________
a 1 = "do not believe" and 5 = "strongly believe."
b 1 = "do not fit" and 5 = "fit very well."


TABLE 6. Internal Consistency of Scales
_____________________________________________________________________

Possible     Respondents'
Scale				Range	Range	 M	SD	alpha	
_____________________________________________________________________

Attitudes Toward Disciplinea	15-75	27-72	47.41	11.40	.85

Methods of Disciplineb		30-90	42-90	78.93	10.78	.90

Acculturationc			16-80	19-61	43.54	12.09	.92
_____________________________________________________________________
a Scale:  1 = "Strongly Disagree," 2 = "Disagree," 3 = "No Opinion," 
  4 = "Agree," and 5 = "Strongly Agree."  Higher scores indicate more 
  of a traditional Cambodian approach of disciplining.
b Scale:  1 = Physical Means, 2 = Emotional Maltreatment, and 3 = Reasoning.
  Higher scores indicate the use of reasoning when disciplining.
c Scale:  1 = Cambodian (Khmer) to 5 = American.
  Higher scores indicate a higher level of acculturation.

TABLE 7. Relationships Among Attitudes Toward Discipline, Methods of
                  Discipline, and Acculturation
_____________________________________________________________________

Variable					r		  p
_____________________________________________________________________

Acculturation
	Attitudes				-.67		.000*
	Methods					 .17		.302

Attitudes
	Methods					-.46		.002*
_____________________________________________________________________
* p < .05.


TABLE 8. Significant Differences in Acculturation and Attitude for Age Entered
                  U.S., Gender, Being a Parent, Employment Status, and Income
_____________________________________________________________________
Variable			  M	  SD		  t	  p
_____________________________________________________________________
ACCULTURATION
Age Entered United States
18 or Less (n = 35)		48.63	 7.34		7.73	.000*
19 or Older (n = 11)		27.36	 9.80

Gender
Female (n = 26)			40.19	14.02		2.42	.020*
Male (n = 20)			47.90	 7.21

Parental Status
Parent (n = 14)			31.86	10.66		6.51	.000*
Not a Parent (n = 30)		49.60	 7.19

Employment Status
Employed (n = 28)		47.89	 6.61		3.05	.004*
Other (n = 16)			37.38	16.11

Income Level
0-$19,999 (n = 25)		40.12	14.06		2.57	.014*
$20,000+ (n = 20)		48.75	 5.87

ATTITUDE
Age Entered United States
18 or Less (n = 34)		42.94	 8.92		5.09	.000*
19 or Older (n = 15)		57.53	10.01

Parental Status
Parent (n = 18)			54.83	11.44		4.03	.000*
Not a Parent (n = 29)		42.97	 8.67

Employment Status
Employed (n = 29)		44.17	 8.65		2.22	.032*
Other (n = 18)			51.44	13.88

Income Level
0-$19,999 (n = 26)		50.35	11.53		2.27	.028*
$20,000+ (n = 22)		43.23	 9.91
_____________________________________________________________________
* p < .05.

TABLE 9. Significant Differences in Acculturation and Attitude for Age and
                   Educational Level
_____________________________________________________________________

Variable				  M	SD	   F	   p
_____________________________________________________________________

Acculturation						15.92	.000*
18-28 (n = 24)a      			50.79	7.50
29-39 (n = 13)				40.69	9.18
40-50 (n = 3)				31.67	9.07
51+ (n = 6)				26.67  11.02	

Acculturation						25.61	.000*
University Graduate (n = 14)		45.64	5.58
Some University (n = 8)			52.25	5.31
Junior/Community College (n = 9)	50.33	5.59
High School (n = 7)			45.29  11.59
Less Than High School (n = 7)a      	21.57	3.87

Attitude						 6.60	.001*
18-28 (n = 23)a      			42.04	9.11
29-39 (n = 13)				47.62  11.19
40-50 (n = 5)				52.80	6.50
51+ (n = 8)a      			59.13  10.93

Attitude						 9.26	.000*
University Graduate (n = 13)a      	40.15	8.02
Some University (n = 8)a      		40.38	9.96
Junior/Community College (n = 10)a	47.00	7.94
High School (n = 8)a      		49.50  11.45
Less Than High School (n = 9)a      	61.00	5.79
_____________________________________________________________________
* p < .05.
a Significant difference. 

BACK TO SURVEY RESULTS


CONTINUE TO NEXT CHAPTER - DISCUSSION


© 2001 The Khmer Institute. All rights Reserved.